Retention election

From Judgepedia

Jump to: navigation, search

A retention election or judicial retention is a periodic process whereby a judge is subject to a vote during an election. A judge is removed from the position if the majority of those voting decree that it will be so.

A judicial retention vote differs from regular voting in that when voting for judicial retention, a voter is not choosing between opposing candidates. In a retention election, the incumbent judge is not being evaluated against an opponent. Rather, the voter expresses approval or disapproval of a particular judge. A judge remains in the position by a simple majority of approval votes.

Retention votes are frequently thought of in connection with the commission-selection, political appointment method of judicial selection. However, some states that choose state Supreme Court justices for their initial term in office using partisan or non-partisan elections, use a retention election for subsequent terms on the court.

Retention votes in 2008

Court Initial term Incumbent Election Date
Alaska Supreme Court Commission/political Robert L. Eastaugh 11/4/2008
Arizona Supreme Court Commission/political Scott Bales 11/4/2008
Connecticut Supreme Court Commission/political Christine Vertefeuille 11/4/2008
Florida Supreme Court Commission/political Charles T. Wells 11/4/2008
Indiana Supreme Court Commission/political Randall T. Shephard, Brent E. Dickson, Theodore R. Boehm 11/4/2008
Iowa Supreme Court Commission/political Mark S. Cady, Daryl L. Hecht, Brent R. Appel 11/4/2008
Kansas Supreme Court Commission/political Kay McFarland, Lee A. Johnson 11/4/2008
Missouri Supreme Court Commission/political Patricia Breckenridge 11/4/2008
New Mexico Supreme Court Partisan election Patricio Serna 11/4/2008
New Mexico Supreme Court Partisan election Charles Daniels 11/4/2008
State of New York Court of Appeals Commission/political Carmen Beauchamp Ciparick 11/4/2008
Oklahoma Supreme Court Commission/political John F. Reif 11/4/2008
Oklahoma Supreme Court Commission/political Tom Colbert 11/4/2008
Oklahoma Supreme Court Commission/political Joseph M. Watt 11/4/2008
Tennessee Supreme Court Commission/political William Koch, Jr. 11/4/2008
Wyoming Supreme Court Commission/political William U. Hill 11/4/2008


External links